I am surprised by some of the lack luster reviews. Our experience was nothing but great!
My husband and I went here for the first time last night and loved every minute, bite and drink. For an appetizer, we started off with the M&T's Pierogies. These things are amazing. Deep fried pierogies covered with hot sauce, ranch dressing, FETA, and gyro meat. Let's be honest- everything is better with feta and this was no exception. For our entrees, we had a chicken gyro and souvlaki gyro. Both were great. The pita was very well done and exceptionally soft and the meat was cooked to perfection. For drinks, we both ordered beers and both were the way they were supposed to be: ice cold and delicious.
This place is a true Pittsburgh staple and we will definitely be returning! :)