Why 5 stars? It is on the water and most of the seating is outdoors. I can think of 2 other places in all of greater Cleveland that can boast the same. Everything else about the bar other than location is just satisfactory.
The indoor bar itself is nice enough but really small; the draw of the place is the huge outdoor dining area. They have one pavilion with picnic tables and a huge grassy area with tables. There is also a deck with a dj. The crowd reminds me of a high school cafeteria; each picnic table in the grassy outdoor area contains a different type of group, ranging from bikers to hambones to two women holding hands. It is sort of refreshing, actually to see so many different crowds coming together in the same spot. There are outdoor port-a-johns, but don't be fooled. The inside bar also has bathrooms. Yes, the sunset grille is extremely casual.