If I had to rate sushi bars in Madison Sushi Muramota would come in third or fourth. (1st: Red, 2nd: Fuji)
Here is my issue with Sushi Muramota. When I plan to eat raw fish at a place I expect the place to be immaculate. The level of cleanliness has to be way better than a standard restaurant that cooks your food. On maybe the 4th or 5th time I went there we sat at the sushi bar and I just felt the bar was dirty and the cooler where they keep the fish was not up to my standards. That completely turned me off and I have been unable to go back. Maybe it was just that day or it's just me but with other sushi options in the area I don't plan on going back anytime soon!