Their pizza definitely gets 4 or 5 stars from me. However the rest of my experience here scaled back my general rating to 3. My friend and I arrived here, and walked in and saw the generally unimpressive interior of this place - kinda looked like it was decorated a decade or two ago and hasn't been updated since. We saw no sign indicating whether we should seat ourselves or not, so we waited. And waited. And then sat in a bench, and waited some more. About 10-15 minutes later we actually had to grab a waitress as she was taking someone else's order, and asked if we are supposed to seat ourselves. She apologized for not seeing us and sat us down. This fashion of slow if not complete lack of service continued for the rest of the night.
But as I said, the pizza was delicious. Ingredients tasted fresh, and the menu had a nice Italian selection beyond just the pizzas that they are so known for - all for reasonable prices. It's just not quite as enjoyable when you're annoyed by the service.