Do I miss the old Magnus (previous incarnation of this restaurant)? Most certainly. Both the Spanish and Norwegian versions. It was the best bar in Madison, hands down.
But I have to say that Tempest is among the most under-appreciated bar/restaurants in Madison.
Yes, you can go to Merchant, just up the block, but you can't get a seat and you can't hear the person sitting next to you. And the place is just an industrial space. Tempest is genuine plaster walled vintage. And that boat in the front lobby is a solid wood beauty.
Drinks are expertly made, the seafood is fresh, and if you get the #2 tower between 2 couples. you have the equivalent of 4-5 appetizers. Plus the clam shell is beautiful, and if you close your eyes, you are back at Magnus.
Again, one of the most under appreciated bars in Madison.