A friend of mine frequents Slice of New York because it is Halal so the pepperoni is made from beef instead of pork. When I said I wanted to try it to see what beef pepperoni tastes like, my friend told me he was in no way responsible if I did not enjoy my pizza. Turns out he didn't need to make this disclaimer because their beef pepperoni was just as good as pork pepperoni and I did enjoy my pizza. The crust was similar to Pizza Pizza crust and the sauce and cheese were both standard yumminess.
This place has been a fixture on Groupon Now for the last week or so ($6 for $10), so we ended up going with one other person and ordering an entire large pizza, which was a decent size - good enough to be split by 2 guys and 1 girl with no complaints. A one topping pizza was $11.99+tax and we didn't have to wait too long for it, around 10 minutes while it was prepped and cooked in the pizza oven.
The tables and floor in this place are pretty cheap and worn, but clean enough and there are a bunch of four person tables, way more than a typical take-out pizza joint. I would eat here again, and maybe try their shawarma, although aforementioned friend warned me against that too. =)