In my opinion it's 3.5 stars worth of good. The food was amazing. We had the new york strip for 2, oysters, bread with melted cheese and poutine. Everything was well done and delicious. I wouldn't order the bread and cheese again though, I just don't feel it's enough to justify the 16$ spent (4 small brioche buns and a small pot of melted cheese.) However the steak, poutine and oysters I would return for. We have plans to return for the meat and cheese board. So why just 3.5? The service was very off-putting. We waited so long for drinks to be brought first of all. Like 20 minutes. Each time. There was a lot of strange laughing from our waitress, she seemed so anxious it made me anxious. Also I felt like the bathrooms and ambiance did not meet my expectations for spending 200 on a 2 person meal. So, I would go again, but just for a drink and some lunch, I would not go all out on a dinner here.
Just another thought, I'm all for a small menu done well but think this is on the extreme side of small. To the point that I wouldn't have ordered an entree if my boyfriend didn't really want steak and the one he wanted (out of 2) was an entree for 2. I was looking forward to escargot and bone marrow and it was taken from the menu which was a bummer.