I had heard there was a Maid-Rite somewhere around Madison, enter Nifty 50s Sandwich Shop. A total blast from my past! The sandwiches were just like I remembered eating at Maid-Rite with my grandparents when I was a child. (The staff kind of reminded me of my grandparents too.) :) The malts and shakes and fountain sodas were just like old school pharmacy style. To make the experience all that much better, the juke box is free!!! Overall this place has my vote. A note-do not go here if you are in a major rush as I think the husband and wife team run the whole place on their own so service is not super-fast, but it's well worth the wait.