I've been to Waypoint a number of times now. We live in McFarland and it is nice to know that we don't have to travel downtown every time we want a yummy dinner. McFarland is great place to live but the food options are pretty minimal unless you want fast food or a super club atmosphere. Waypoint is just a short 5 minute drive for us and the reason we frequent so often.
The food is always fantastic and the beer selection is great. I've tried half the menu and never had a complaint. The patio is also great for those nice fall/summer Wisconsin days.
The only issue I have is the service can lead you to desire more. Like I said, we've been there at least 8 times now and at least half of those times the servers and or bartenders are not as friendly or quick as you'd hope for. No one should have to sit at the bar for over five minutes before they get served with both bartenders walking by multiple times. Especially when the bar is only half full! You could at least stop by and say, 'hey folks, I will be back in a few minutes here is a menu to look at while you wait.'
If they can get the servers to be more attentive this place would definitely deserve 5 stars.