Let's be honest here. I like reubens. Tip Top has best reuben I have had in Madison. Best. Here it is folks. I probably shouldn't let you in on this because that's one less reuben for me. This bad boy has the perfect balance of thick cut pastrami, kraut and 1,000 island sauce with ample melty Swiss on sour dough rye. Damn. I challenge anyone to find a better reuben. You should try it with the Tip Top sauce instead of 1000 island. Outrageous. Please remember to tip handsomely and you're welcome.