This was my first time here. My family loved it! It was a really nice atmosphere. Our waiter - Miguel - was really great and friendly--willing and able to answer questions.
As far as the food, it was also lovely. The scallops are amazing here-I would highly recommend them. The antipasti was a nice platter for sharing. And yes, the butter cake is pretty good (the fruit made you feel a little less guilty and offset the flavorings). Ours was cold, I noticed other reviews talked about a warm version.
I would highly recommend it and I will be coming back. It was really nice to sit on the patio in the evening too and the heaters kept us warm.