I've only been here once, but I had a good time. The food was nothing to write home about, but it has a great atmosphere. The fruity drinks aren't cheap, but they're also not ridiculous (6-10 bucks). I'd go back.
Oh, and one exception to the so-so food were the conch fritters. They were a little different than I've had before, with more crunch and spice. Awesome.
Don't forget, this place does not accept credit or debit cards! I guess there's an ATM, but, seriously, I don't want to have to go to the ATM.