I was prepared to conclude that this place is a typical tourist trap that has mediocre food at terrible prices. Thankfully, I was rather far off base. We went here on a recent Saturday and got there very early (5:15pm). We were the only table, but that didn't deter us.
The interior is a little bit dated, but not in a bad way. We liked it.
The server was very helpful and had several good suggestions of tapas to order. We sampled many things, each of which was good. The gazpacho was a standout: acidic, spicy, and hearty. Just perfect. The garlic shrimp, which is very easy to mess up, was done nicely. The wine selection was excellent and well-priced.
We'll likely return here on our next trip to Montreal.