We moved back to WI about 11 years ago and ate at Fitzgeralds shortly after that. We were not impressed back then and it took us over a decade to return.
Last month our party of 6 ate there for Easter. It was fantastic.
We were seated promptly at the time of our reservation and the entire staff was very pleasant and attentive.
The entire place has been remodeled and it no longer strikes us as a dingy old-style Supper Club. Everything seemed fresh and very clean.
Despite the fact Fitzgeralds was serving only a Buffet for the Easter service, everything was very, very good. The salad bar is outstanding and provides great variety, and the chicken, ribs, dressing, potatoes, etc. was all fresh, hot, and extremely tasty.
The soft custard was a big hit with our kids, and the huge desert table was a big hit with the rest of us.
We'll definitely be back. Well done Fitzgeralds!