I'm not particularly keen on their beer, but then again, I've not drank there in a while. However, this place serves some pretty damn tasty food and I have to say that they have the best damn Reuben sandwich I've had in Madison. Friends of mine have recommended the steak and they make them fairly decent if I remember right. Their burgers and nachos seem pretty popular around, but I've not had a chance to try them out fully yet.
The atmosphere is nice for a bar, not ridiculously noisy or trashy, yet pretty fun to be around.
Will need to go there more often before I can give a full review.