Pretty disappointing.
First: we were seated directly opposite the only other occupied table in the section. Not great for conversation.
Second: waitress seemed confused when we asked to see the Happy Hour menu.
Third: Ordered the Coconut Crusted Wahoo. The fish was translucent. Not cooked at all. We thought maybe we missed something on the menu about it being "Sushi style". The broccoli and rice were barely warm. The waitress was grossed out by the fish, and took it back for a replacement. The second plate was at least edible, but this time overcooked. No word at all from the kitchen or management.
Fourth: while the Happy Hour menu shows "Craft Draft Pints" for $4, I was charged $5.50. The glass was the smallest "pint" I have seen.
We've tried Caballero Grill several times now, but there is always something that just isn't quite up to par. I guess we're always hoping for something other than national chain restaurants, but it's not Caballero for us.