I dined at Caffe Portobello on Saturday night. I brought a date, and we both enjoyed the experience.
CP is tucked away in a strip mall next to a salon and a dentist's office. Don't let the surrondings fool you. It is a cozy spot. The wall are a warm red and the lighting is low. Seating options include table/chairs, booths and the bar. There was one large screen TV featuring the World Series. Patio seating is available, and the circular bar is half-inside half-outside so that all parties can get served.
Also, there is live music at night from Thursday through Sunday.
The menu offers a diverse selection of American fare. We had the Chicken Marsala and Chop Salad. They were both good, but not great. I've heard the sliders are incredible.
The setting was 5 stars, the food was 3 stars. I averaged it out to 4 stars. :)