I went to 6 different summerlicious events this year and Canoe gets the top rating.
My list:
1) Canoe
2) Auberge du Pommier
3) Epic
4) Biff
5) Jump
6) Lucien
Why did Canoe top the list? It excelled on all three fronts:
A) SERVICE
B) AMBIANCE
C) FOOD
Even though we did not reserve a window seat, they obliged when we asked for one. Also, the waiter escorted us around the restaurant when we wanted to take pictures - even offering suggestions for picture locations.
The view was spectacular. I was seated right by the window overlooking the ACC and Hanlan Point (Toronto's Islands). For once, the food had competition: I kept glancing away from my dishes to look at the scenery.
As for the food, I have to admit that it did not make me scream in delight but everything was cooked just right (texture / seasoning / balance). Presentation was killer. The highlight for me was my dessert - it was soooo smooth and delicate.
I plan to have my AMEX ready for the next *licious event!