I am unsure why people did not like Don Vito's. My husband and I had a fantastic dinner here. I had the seafood pasta in the spicy tomato broth and the pasta was cooked perfectly al dente, and the seafood was perfect and flavorful. Normally seafood in this type of dish is overcooked. My husband had the ravioli and again, was cooked perfectly. The tomato cream sauce tasted fresh.
Another highlight is the tomato / garlic relish they serve with the bread, fabulous.
While this may not compare to some of the high end italian places in town but we have never had a better prepared meal in town for the price. The wines were also wonderful and decently priced.
Look for the South Point January mailer for a buy 1 meal get 1 free here, it makes this restaurant an even greater bargain.