Food and presentation wise - definitely a solid 5! The menu is well thought through, both taste and looks. The waiting staff surely knows their menu very well.
The portions might be on a smaller side for some dishes, unusual for Montreal if you ask me, so better check with the waiting staff to not remain hungry!
We were a little surprised about lack of beer in _brasserie_, but this is just a rather minor setback.
Overall - definitely coming back once i have a chance :)