I wanted to give this place 4 or even 5 stars, but I just cannot.
The Not So Good: This place has an awesome drink list. A full list of tap beers, 2 more pages of bottles. An awesome list of speciality drinks. So when J and I came in on a Sunday afternoon and tried to order two separate beers, I was stunned when they didn't have either one of them. Why tease your patrons with thinking they can get a big selection if they can't? Also, J got a burger - which was too peppery - and truffle fries. $17?!?! Seriously. That's just too much.
The good: I got an awesome salad called the Hand Looper - onions, oyster mushrooms, beets, goat cheese and shallot vinagrette - all awesome. I added steak which was cooked perfectly. All in all, awesome. The dressing was super light, but still really flavorful and it was on a gigantic bed of fresh spinach.
I think I would go back, but it's hard to say.