Great atmosphere, food is so-so. I had fried calamari which was huge, but otherwise only so-so and nothing special. The dipping sauce was meh too.
I also had the lobster mac and cheese which was neither creamy nor cheesy... in fact, it was surprisingly oniony, which is not what mac and cheese is supposed to be like. It tasted like macaroni with onions and lobster in butter, with some cheese sprinkled on top.
Because the calamari was so big and the mac and cheese wasn't great, I barely touched the mac and cheese, so the waitress did offer to get me something else when she saw I wasn't a big fan (though I didn't make a scene of it at all), so I'll give them a bonus for great service!