With such a disparity in the reviews here, I had to check things out.
Meh. It was okay.
The atmosphere was great, and they had a good selection of beers available. The food though was only so-so.
Burgers: We had the mini burgers, which were fresh and tasty with real cheddar cheese. The side of garlic mayo was very delicious.
The Poutine: Fries...not as hot as I would have liked, but the gravy was okay. I doubt the curds were really curds, but more likely mozzarella chunks. Which is okay too I guess.
Poutine, 2 mini burgs, 2 Mill Streets = 24 bucks.
I dunno....its a good place to go with friends to sit down and drink and eat, but Craft Burger just has more flavour, and would still be my first choice.