Anatolia has been a going concern for at least 10 years, and most folks say the same thing.
1) The food is generally pretty good, depends on how busy they get, and who's cooking.
2) The portions are usually a wee bit on the small side. I've been going to Anatolia for at least 10 years, and, to make up for portion size, I pig out on the breads and appetizers.
3) The music nights, with palm readers and belly dancers who are many times better than the ones in the top Restaurants in Taksim Square, make anyone's night really worth while.
4) If you can't afford Istanbul, Anatolia is a pretty good second.
5) Don't gripe about the prices, you are helping Aysha make a living from a pretty small floor area.