First, Maestro's delivers. The actual restaurant's employees deliver - not a delivery service - so the friendly person who brings your meal to the door actually *cares* whether it's correct/complete. This matters.
When you call them on the phone, they're actually happy to hear from you. We order maybe once a month or so, but they remember hubby by name, every time.
We've ordered the pizza a couple times. It's really good.
But usually we go for the gyros, which are always delicious. Hubby orders his with extra meat, which makes it an enormous damn sandwich. The 'regular' gyro is plenty filling all on it's own.
My only complaints are with the appetizer menu. Anything in that section of the menu is just about guaranteed to be frozen/packaged and not very good. Given the quality of the other things we've had, I'd love to see Maestro's selling fresh, hand-battered onion rings and calamari!