I have never gotten a sandwich made at this place - I simply come in a grab bagels to take home. So far, I have tried sesame, everything and onion. These bagels are awesome. They taste great and if you freeze them they re-toast well. They taste super fresh even after coming out of the freezer. My boyfriend and I just got another mixed dozen to try. We're really happy a place like this opened so close by! On a sadder note, their "everything bagel" or at least I think that's what it was, didn't do it for me. But the onion and the sesame are to die for!