I love local hometown eateries. So when we were looking for a place for lunch while on the road, the Prairie Diner called out to us. Inside looks like a 50s diner with stainless steel lunch counter and cozy booths. Judging by the area around it, it can't be that old but at least it looks authentic. The service was prompt and friendly, the young cook greeted us when we walked in the front door which appears to be the back door as you enter near the back of the kitchen and restrooms. He also thanked us on our way out. I don't think I've ever seen that before, I figured he must be the owner.
The wife ordered the ultimate omelette, I had the perch lunch. They even had a perch breakfast on the menu which comes with eggs - only in Wisconsin! The atmosphere and service made you feel right at home. The food was fairly average. We're not complaining, other things are as important as the food in a restaurant. A much more memorable experience than a stop at McDonald's next door.