So maybe I just don't get it? I know this place is pretty popular and has had good reviews but honestly I was very disappointed.
Ordered the three meatballs in the mushroom gravy. First of all the meatballs were TINY...maybe the size of a golf ball and were basically buried in this thick soup of a gravy. I literally had to dig to find them. Secondly, holy sodium Batman. By the time I found and had a bite out of my second meatball my lips were burning and I was downing water like it was going out of style. Needless to say I didn't come close to finishing the two remaining meatballs.
My partner had the three meatballs with sauce. Also very tiny but didn't seem to suffer from the salt issue so perhaps it was the gravy that was the culprit. He wasn't blown away but said it was decent. Due to the size (or lack thereof), he was still hungry afterwards so he tried a bite from mine and promptly pushed it away.
Looks like there is a new location opening on Roncey (my extended 'hood) so I might try that one just to give it a fair shake but definitely won't go back to the location on College.