I purchased 3 cakes from Noisette and I'm not sure if I just got unlucky on all 3 times, but the cakes were dry. They looked absolutely beautiful. The first one was from the bakery case and I was "told" it was fresh. The 2nd one was ordered in advance and yes, it was fresh, but the sponge cake was sticky and under baked. You will see from the picture. I would NEVER expect this from a professional baker. I have made sponge cakes myself and had them turn out this way once, but then I changed the recipe and was careful with the steps and I never had it turn out the way the cake from Noisette did.
Also, the lemon raspberry cake - we let it sit out at room temperature for 3 hours and the buttercream was still hard like a block of butter!
The macarons were just okay, not really worth purchasing.
I am not willing to buy a cake for the 4th time. 3 times is enough.
I also agree with Angie C., the few times I've visited, the young women who work there are frazzled and not friendly at all, despite it not being busy. A HUGE turnoff.
I will NEVER and have never returned.