I've been to this place twice now. The first time I wanted something non-caffeinated so I got a cherry italian soda. It was delicious, and the price was fine.
Last week I needed a coffee to go and thought I'd give this place a whirl. I got a medium sized light roast and was horrified to see that the only option for creamer was the little individual-size International Coffee creamers that you see in restaurants sometimes. I was really surprised that a place whose main offering is coffee didn't have some sort of little pitcher or carafe with half-and-half or even whole milk. Even Kwik Trip (with their spelling issues) offers half-and-half from a dispenser.
I didn't like the coffee much but I'm pretty sure I didn't add enough sugar and creamer, so I'm not knocking off any stars for that. I'll have to try it again some time to judge it better.
It used to be a small bank and has a wacky layout, but I think that's sort of fun and adds to the hometown/refurbished vibe.