I'm rather surprised at the reviews here. This place is expensive, and the portions are smaller, but that's how high-class dining works. If you want big portions (and often I do, so I understand the desire), go to Nyro's and get a triple gyro plate.
The food is superb, and the waitstaff is excellent. The interior is very cozy and lodge-like (upstairs, anyway). Also, I typically don't like gourmet pizzas (I'm a blue-collar pizza kind of guy) but they really have some excellent pizzas here.
On busy college weekends (like parents' weekend or whatever they call it) it's tough to get a reservation here. It's also the place that visiting scholars are often brought to be dined.
The food will not disappoint.