I've been here twice and tried the mocha, oreo cheesecake cookie, and a chocolate coconut cookie. Everything has been delicious, especially the oreo cheesecake cookie - it's a must-try! My favourite thing about the baked goods is that they're not overly sweet. The flavours are enjoyable because they're not overpowered by sugar.
The cafe itself is clean and quiet. The owner, who served me both times, is very sweet.
The Black Goat Cafe is a wonderful addition to the Lake Shore!