I'm rating this on behalf of my friends and I, because a lot of what they ordered during our latest visit helped with the overall rating.
BYOB/AVV is the popular thing to do, and it's convenient that there's a nearby store to pick up a bottle. It's always busy and loud around dinner time so avoid coming here if you want to have a quiet dinner. No doubt, the goings on at other tables could stimulate conversation at your own table.
If you like seafood, the mussels are a must. This is where my friend's dishes come in to play. Each of them ordered a different mussel dish and were surprised at how many mussels they received on their plate and how delicious their plates' respective sauces were. I've always ordered a pasta dish and have never been disappointed with my choices.
Service has always been pretty good every time. The wait staff is generally attentive (and they don't look that bad either). The chairs are quite comfy even though seating is a bit tight. Prices were pretty reasonable.