I absolutely LOVE the Old Fashioned. It's a true staple of Downtown Madison. The cheesecurds are delicious (just wish the ranch dressing was thicker). And I've never had a bad, or even mediocre, meal. The new addition has really helped with wait times and seating, although I would recommend coming early if you're planning to be there on a busy night. They don't take reservations (bummer). Try the pickled egg in your beer - or the Old Fashioned Burger if you're feeling adventurous and hungry!