I have been to Everly three times now and I want to love it so badly, but each time I have left feeling a little underwhelmed. I gave it 4 stars for the reviews, but was on the fence of giving it 3.
Our most recent trip was for Easter brunch. My parents and grandma were in town from Chicago, and my sister and her husband joined us for brunch out. My parents were huge fans of Bluphies when It used to occupy the space Everly is now in, so we decided to take them to check out the new restaurant. We ordered drinks and my grandma was very impressed with her Bloody Mary. Everyone had a great time and was very satisfied with their food however, my chicken sandwich was a little bland, and honestly something I wouldn't order again.
I'm primarily vegetarian and in past visits I've gotten multiple sides of vegetables. Although their vegetables are tasty, you're basically paying a fairly high price for something I could likely make at home. I appreciate the California fresh vibe, and I've been really wanting to check out their patio... however, Everly is just one of those restaurants that doesn't rank high on my go-to list of places... and definitely not something that I crave. Nonetheless, it's a beautiful restaurant with delicious food and something definitely worth checking out.