This is really just 2.5 stars. I must have gone to a different Grotto than the rest of you. While it was just fine it was certainly nothing special. The food was ok: overcooked salmon, good burger, fair meatballs. Our service, however, was actually comical. It was not our servers fault. He had clearly never been trained (at all). He knew nothing about the menu, nothing about the bar. He was nice as could be but had to leave to ask for answers to any questions that were asked. The manager came by to ask how things were and we told him but it didn't really seem to have much impact. Also, they should really lose that tv in the dining room. This is not some sports bar. If someone that we are going out with wanted to go there that would be ok but otherwise I don't see us returning.