So many of the restaurants in Montreal, while great, have some pretense and attitude. Not O'Thym. There is a nice open feel to the restaurant without feeling cramped. Wait staff was friendly and prompt, but the food was spectacular. Had the Magret de Canard which was flavorful and well prepared. Wife had a flank steak that was also quite good. The palate cleanser "Trou Normond" while enjoyable probably wasn't worth $7 IMO. It was especially refreshing to bring our own wine rather than to continue to get baked by restaurants for wine that is either too expensive or not worthy of the food. Refreshingly, there was no horse on the menu, but I realize as an American that I am biased.
There are a million great restaurants in Montreal, but I think for the price point and quality of the food that dining at O'Thym is a pretty good option with which you won't be disappointed.