I'm not much of a donut person but I will make an exception for a Hurts Donut. This is a fairly new addition to Middleton Wisconsin--right next to the police station. Ha! They have a variety of specialty donuts, most with creative names such as the Homer Simpson. My personal favorite has been the blueberry, and the lemon filled donuts. The Middleton, WI location is a two story building with the top floor functioning as more of a game room. They offer hot chocolate on tap, and it's a fun place to stop in with the kids. I find that my coworkers appreciate a box brought to the office as well.
My complaints are generally poor customer service and not the most friendly staff. The donuts are also fairly pricey considering they are just donuts. They do offer cheaper options of half-dozen or a dozen donuts if you don't custom pick which donuts you want and let Hurts Donuts pick them for you. Although, I would recommend picking your own.