This place has got some great character. I actually wish I had gone here for drinks because it's sweet. The steaks are solid although if you don't want a rare steak, then I would suggest asking for well done. We went here for restaurant week and my friend unfortunately was not thrilled with the bloody steak we received. I loved it, but that is not everyone.
There are a few good places to get steak in Madison, but this place is the most down to earth. Other places will be a bit stuffy if that is not your thing (e.g. white table clothes).