Surprisingly not terrible. Creepy building, yes. Food, not bad.
The minestrone was alright. The fresh bread was good. The spumoni is not bad.
I got the combo of Mushroom Sauce and the Mizithra Brown Butter Sauce. Skip the mushroom or any combo involving the marinara. It is not that great.
The MIzithra is pretty awesome though. EXTREMELY cheesy (not in a gooey way, but in a salty buttery rich way)... I could feel my arteries clogging.
The best was probably the garlic Mizithra - pretty much the basic jazzed up with garlic, bacon and mushrooms. The husband chose well with that selection.
IF I was made to come again, I would get the Garlic Mizithra.
But honestly? For these prices (about $12/plate), I could (and would) make a freakin Italian feast at home.