I went here again recently and though the experience as a whole was good, there is still something that needs to be said: smallest portion sizes EVER.
Despite how good the food is, it's kind of annoying. You're anticipating this awesome thing you ordered and it then it arrives, and it's supposed to look all cool and minimalist and simple on a white plate but you can't get over the fact that there is literally a piece of fish the size of your palm with some sauce drizzled over it and two pieces of asparagus just lying there on a plate the size of a clock. It might look "fancier", but I'd guess that most Pittsburghers don't really care and just want their food. Tamari, you're going to have to pull some gestalt tricks or something to convince me that there is more food than there actually is on my plate (nice try with the bowl with the 5 inch rim though...).
Lobster Mac & Cheese and the Dark + Stormy was good, though. Although, thinking back on it, the drink was also unreasonably tiny for $8. The best thing about this place is still probably the service, at least they are super nice!