We've been to Jimmy's twice in the last couple of months and it's been consistent both times. My husband LOVES Veal Parmigiana but has a hard time finding places that do it right. This place does it right! Thin cut, never dry. I've had a smattering of things.
Lasagna-Good, not great. I like a drier lasagna and this has alot of sauce
Gnocchi with vodka sauce-Really Good. Not overcooked, lots of sauce
Friends have had:
Chicken Limone: This was excellent. Just the right amount of lemon. Wish there were capers, but thats ok.
We've had wings(hot)-Very good! Asked for well done and that's exactly how we got them.
Fried Ravioli: Just ok. Typical fried food
Rapini and Beans: Very Good! I could eat this as a meal with some angel hair pasta.
Overall, this is a good place for pretty good food. I don't leave feeling like I ate a brick because it sits so heavy. Also like the ambiance of this place but I'm a Bears fan, so I feel right at home. :)