Tomato Pie was recommended to me by a patient - he raved about the pizza! Raved enough that I quickly added it to my restaurant list of places to try. Due to only being open for the summer season, I was only able to try it now. And it did not disappoint!
I arrived and had to wait in line for patio seating as the night was absolutely exquisite. Plants and umbrellas enclose the patio area, making it feel cozy and private. Our waitress was quick to serve us our drinks and take our orders. The prices appear to be on the higher side based on the appearance of the restaurant; however after watching other guests receive their meals, the portion sizes are very generous and could easily be split between two individuals. My friend and I ordered a medium pepperoni pizza to share and we did not leave a crumb behind! The two of us ate the entire thing - the cheese was so melty, the pepperoni small and greasy, and the sauce so fresh and flavorful! And the crust? Just perfect! Thin, with a light crisp along the edge. Needless to say, we were delighted with our choice and I would love to go back and try out some of the salad options that they have to offer.
Things to keep in mind: cash only, BYOB, and the parking lot is very small - so be prepared to wait for spot if the restaurant is as busy as it was tonight, or park in the overflow by the bike rental. I highly recommend checking this locally own pizza joint out!