I live in such close proximity to Bellitalia that it's just silly last night was my first visit. However, it won't be my last because YUM!!! It's a cute little hole in the wall with lots of character. Upon walking in, the aromas alone made me really glad to be there. Our server was lovely and attentive and had great suggestions whenever we asked. The prices are reasonable and the portions are quite generous.
I ordered the carbonara (it came with garlic bread) and my friend got a pizza. The carbonara was wonderful! Everything about it screamed homemade. And the bacon........the bacon was perfection and just the right amount too. It wasn't at all a heavy dish like an Alfredo. I had some left over to take home, thank goodness (even thought I wanted to eat the entire bowl). The garlic bread was your basic garlic bread - nothing special, but it sufficed.
My only wish was that the pasta had been fresh, but honestly, the dish was super delicious regardless and it's something I would totally order again. My friend really enjoyed her pizza as well. She loves their chocolate cake too, but they were all out, which in retrospect is probably a good sign with it being so popular.
Give Bellitalia a try. We're really glad we did!