Maybe it was a 4.5...
Disclaimer: I know the owner.
I also know they put a TON of work and $$ into rebranding the business and today was my third visit and it was great.
I had the lunch special of small salad and 8" pizza. The House Salad was perfect size (perhaps needed a pinch of salt or some olives?). I had the Buffalo Chicken Pizza and devoured it.
Sitting at the bar with great company looking at the great selection of libations. Really liked it. The staff was outgoing and friendly.
I'm a fan!