I have been to Arepa Cafe three times now since last summer. I decided to give it a try after my friend showed me pictures of the arepas online after she discovered the restaurant from BlogTO- they are as gorgeous in real like as they are in all of the pictures! Each time I have eaten there, I have tried a different arepa; I have tried the grilled chicken, pork (wasn't shredded when I asked for shredded, but still delicious), and the plantain and black bean one. All were amazing and it's hard to pick a favourite since they are all so different, but I think if I had to get one of those again, it'd be the plantain one.
They are very generous with their toppings and the corn-based flat bread is amazing, great for those on a gluten free diet. Also, the sauces they bring you for the arepas are great too. The aioli and the red hot sauce are my favourite (the hot sauce is extremely spicy, and I love spicy food!).
I highly recommend this place if you are looking for something different and have never tried an Arepa/Venezuelan cuisine before. It is especially nice in the summer time when the front garage door is open!