This place first won me over when I was ten and I used to bike up to buy New York Zeltzer Seltzer Cream Soda. The same family is still running it twenty years later and they are just as nice now as they were then.
They have lots of made to order sandwiches (hot and cold), soups, chips, ice cream, you name it. Great drink selection and an evil little collection of HOMEMADE cookies and individual slices of cakes and cobblers by the register. They cater too (deli trays, shrimp platters, etc.) The food isn't fancy or especially creative, but they make a darn good breakfast sandwich and really anything else made on the griddle. It's a great place to grab a sandwich on the go. You'll get a smile with your order too!