We gave a 3 because of two things 1. The ridiculous 18% gratuity added for parties of 6 or more. Patrons should NEVER be forced to pay anything, especially this much!!!! And we were only 6 people!! 2. We sat at the back near the patio door and it was open...and we had to keep closing it. It's not summer and it was cold which made the first half of the night unbearable. I think they finally got the hint and kept it closed. The food was very good and fresh. My SMALL AND TEENY Cosmo was $14.00!!!! So, even though this place is cute and quaint and the service was nice, this party of 6 won't be returning for reasons stated above.