3.5 stars.
We came here for lunch on a Sunday using an expired Groupon of which had a value of $19 (originally for 4 people for $40 promo value) but the details of the Groupon didn't mention that we needed 4 people to use the actual value. Anyways, even before we got there, we called to make sure we can use it and the staff on the line assured us it would be okay.
When we got there and proceeded to order, the same staff told us that we had to order 4 things in order for the groupon to work and that he had talked to the boss who confirmed this. Obviously we were very upset. He even told us to come back instead. I did not appreciate his lack of care and remarks. But we had traveled all this way so we decided to order 4 smaller menu items (he had told us only appetizers and entrees allowed).
So finally, we ordered four items: 2 crab cakes, the Boston Clam Chowder and Mahi Mahi Fish and Chips which comes with coleslaw. The soup came first and it was good. Not too salty and had a lot of clams in it. Very hearty and I would order this again if I ever go back.
The crab cakes did not look very appealing but it was surprisingly tasty. The portion of the cake was big so I couldn't finish mine and gave half to my boyfriend.
Finally the fish and chips was a generous portion and the batter was not too heavy. Of that dish though, the best part is probably the coleslaw (we got the creamy original one, it also comes in vinigrate). It tasted super fresh and not overly creamy, just perfectly balanced!
The decor itself is small, dark and pretty dingy so it would probably just be a good quick bite place.
Overall, the service was mediocre (we had to ask for water) but the food was tasty.