Village Tavern is a great place to go when you're in the mood for American food. They have a broad variety of appetizers and entrees, and a yummy selection of sandwiches too. The restaurant is insanely cozy, with bubbled glass window panes and a giant fireplace at the head of the main dining room.
Their french onion soup and New York Strip steak are my two favorites. Great place to go when you aren't sure what you're in the mood to eat -- there's so many options at Village Tavern. Naomi Garnice gives it four stars.